JB- Do you think it's important to win Idol?
JPL- Is it important? I mean, no. Yes and no. It's cool. It's great. I think there are definitely big downsides with it. I think the biggest downfall is that there's no time for artist development. There's no time for whoever this person is to kind of grow into a sound that's unique and not so general.
JB- Would you have preferred to win?
JPL- Let me put it this way- I'm happy where I'm at. I don't think it's a matter of preference. It is what it is and I don't even think whether I'm happy or unhappy, it's just kind of like I am where I am. It's like I have to be happy with that.
JB- And where you are now you're doing it your own way, on your own time. You're creating your own path, aren't you?
JPL- Right. Absolutely.
JB- So maybe you would have preferred to do it this way instead of actually winning because you're not being rushed through everything and you're not as in control of everything.
JPL- That's for sure. There's a lot more control. There are definite upsides to… I don't know, I think I would have been able to make it work no matter where I was. I was very clear in my mind about what I wanted to do. Well, more about what I didn't want to have happen. You know, I wasn't exactly sure about a lot of things. But I didn't want to be a ballad singer. I wanted to be in control and I wanted a lot of these things. And I think may have been able to pull it off even if I had won. I don't know. Maybe that's just speculation, I guess.
JB- Thinking back three years ago - or even six years ago, before Idol hit the airwaves - where did you see yourself headed career wise? Did you ever think of becoming a pen salesman like Simon first suggested?
JPL- (laughing) No. No I never thought about it. I was planning on going to medical school. I was an English student in college and I was thinking I'll go be a doctor and have a secure life and blah, blah, blah. But my father, he's a musician, you know, I grew up with a lot of music in the house and he had some success in the 60s. My whole life I kind of grew up thinking that I would be a musician and I was pretty surprised at myself just before Idol auditions. Just before I decided to go I was surprised that I hadn't done anything about that kind of desire up to that point of time in my life. I thought this might be a shot - an opportunity - to possibly live that dream that I had growing up.
JB- So you weren't really pursing it at all prior to Idol?
JPL- No, I really wasn't. You know, American Idol's my first attempt.
JB- When did you first fall in love with music then?
JPL- I was really in love with music from a really young age. I don't know. I mean, I liked a lot of things. I was really a diverse kid. I was in choir but I was also in a rock and roll band. And I was in theatre and I really enjoyed music theatre stuff and appreciated all that stuff for what it was. I don't know. I mean, I definitely fell in love with music then. And every time I hear like a new artist or a new song that I really like, you know, I'm kind of in love with music all over again. It just reminds me of why I like it so much.
JB- What is it about music that you love?
JPL- I think it's definitely transcendent as a form of communication. They say it was one of the first things that developed in early humans, even before a lot of core language skills were developed. Even in primitive cultures you find very complex music structures. I think it's just a very high and universal form of communicating and being able to express yourself and I could connect with it.